Precision in motion: Rolex vs. Tudor Watch Movements

Before we dissect the differences, let’s identify what Rolex and Tudor movements share. At their core, both feature automatic movements with three hands and a central second hand, accompanied by a date mechanism. This commonality forms the foundation upon which their distinctions are built. However, as we explore further, you’ll discover that even these seemingly similar components hold unique characteristics.

One of the most iconic features of Rolex watches is the instantaneous date change precisely at midnight. Rolex achieves this feat with a mechanism more intricate than what you find in a typical ETA movement, which is commonly used in Tudor watches. Rolex’s instantaneous date change is not only quick but also precise, jumping to the next date at the stroke of midnight. In contrast, the ETA movement in Tudor watches transitions more gradually, with the numbers slowly moving within the date window until the full date becomes visible. This subtle yet remarkable distinction speaks to the attention to detail Rolex places in their timepieces.

Moving deeper into the movements, there is another noteworthy difference to encounter – the balance wheel. When you inspect the balance wheel of an ETA movement, commonly found in Tudor watches, you’ll notice a flat hairspring. This flat hairspring is a fundamental design used in many ETA movements, and it’s relatively straightforward to adjust. A watchmaker can manipulate it with simple tools like tweezers to alter the active length of the hairspring, consequently affecting the watch’s rate. 

Rolex, on the other hand, employs a more intricate approach. Their balance wheel features mass screws located on the outside, allowing for precise adjustments. To make these adjustments, a specialized tool known as the Microstella tool is required. By shifting the mass towards the center of the balance, a watchmaker can fine-tune the watch’s accuracy. Rolex’s method, while more complex, offers a higher degree of precision in regulating the watch’s rate.

Have you ever noticed the silent, almost imperceptible sound of a Rolex winding? This distinctive characteristic can be attributed to Rolex’s use of a dual bearing and rotor axle inside the jewel bearing. The absence of ball bearings contributes to this quiet winding action. However, it’s worth noting that over time, the rotor axle in Rolex watches can wear down, requiring replacement. 

In contrast, movements with ball bearings tend to be louder during winding. Nevertheless, ball bearings are generally more reliable in the long run, which is why Rolex transitioned to them with the caliber 32 movement.

Now, let’s shift our focus to the external attributes of these watches. Both Rolex and Tudor, especially in their vintage models, share a similar design language. However, there are key distinctions. For instance, Rolex introduced the use of 904L steel in their watches earlier than Tudor. While Rolex makes a significant marketing claim about this steel, its practical implications, especially for watchmakers during servicing, are not as substantial as one might think. The critical factor for a successful refurbishment lies in the shape of the case, and in this regard, Rolex and Tudor cases are remarkably similar.

Both Rolex and Tudor have dive watches in their repertoire, and it’s interesting to note the differences in their water resistance capabilities. Rolex boasts a water resistance rating of 300 meters, whereas Tudor’s dive watches typically offer 200 meters of water resistance. 

The primary factor contributing to this variance is the type of crystal used. Rolex employs a sapphire crystal, which is highly resistant to pressure and scratches. In contrast, most of Tudor’s dive watches feature acrylic glass. While this material has its merits, it tends to compress under high pressure, making it less effective at maintaining water resistance compared to a sapphire crystal. 

When it comes to servicing and ensuring water resistance, watchmakers have a checklist of tasks to perform. Gaskets, crystals, and their condition are meticulously examined and replaced if necessary. A thin layer of grease is applied to ensure a proper seal.

Now, let’s address the practical aspects of owning these watches. From a financial perspective, Tudor watches are typically more cost-effective to service. This affordability arises from the widespread use of ETA movements in Tudor watches. The abundance of spare parts and the accessibility of those parts keep servicing costs reasonable. In contrast, Rolex movements are unique to the brand, limiting access to parts and potentially increasing servicing costs. 

In terms of reliability, Rolex holds the edge. Rolex movements, particularly the caliber 31, are renowned for their durability and longevity. However, like any mechanical movement, they require periodic servicing, typically every three to five years, to maintain optimal performance. The same holds true for Tudor watches with ETA movements.

While ETA movements in Tudor watches offer practicality and cost-effectiveness, the allure of a Rolex with a manufacturer movement is undeniable. Owning a Rolex means possessing a timepiece where every part is meticulously crafted and assembled by a skilled watchmaker. There’s a sense of exclusivity and craftsmanship that comes with a Rolex that’s hard to match. 

In conclusion, the choice between a Rolex and a Tudor ultimately comes down to personal priorities. If you prioritize cost-effective servicing and practicality, a Tudor with an ETA movement is an excellent choice. However, if you seek the pinnacle of craftsmanship and are willing to invest in a timepiece that’s not just a watch but a symbol of precision and prestige, a Rolex with a manufacturer movement is the ultimate choice. 

In the end, whether you opt for the quiet elegance of Rolex or the practical reliability of Tudor, both brands offer exceptional watches that stand the test of time.

Founded in 2013, CHRONEXT has created an innovative digital platform for the buying and selling of Certified Pre-Owned and Vintage watches. Combining the ease of access and convenience of a website with the first-class service of a boutique, CHRONEXT provides support at all stages of acquiring and owning a luxury watch. Watchmakers inspect each watch through a 17-step authenticity and quality control process and issue a 24-month CHRONEXT guarantee.

More information at www.chronext.com